The Shining

Like so many Kubrick films, this was edited after release and some scenes removed, in some countries. Recent versions have restored some of these bits.

There has been so much written about this film, and we have very little new to add.

At the time, the photography, especially the use of the new fangled Steadicam, was something of a revelation.

The book on which it is based is pretty awful. The story does not make much sense, and many regard the film rather as Kubrick’s version of Kramer versus Kramer. We are documenting the collapse of a family by tv here.

The use of red, white and blue is unsubtle.

There are so many articles about the inconsistencies in the plot, but we just think that the shoot was so long that errors popped in and they really don’t have great significance.

Lots has been written about the multiple takes Kubrick used. This is all very interesting, but it’s what is on the screen that counts, not all the other guff.

Barry Lyndon

Kubrick loved the cinema. He wanted his films to be seen on the big screen under the best possible conditions: good sound, a clean and intact print, comfortable chairs…

To that end he had spies out checking on showings and making notes to report back (I know, I sat next to one once).

We wonder what he would have thought of the current state of yer average multiplex: they are expensive, projection quality is often poor, sound can be tinny and the digital projection is lacking. There is no replacement for actual film.

Barry Lyndon is an historical epic. It covers, over three hours, the efforts of an Irish country bumpkin who wants money and power and a title.

Visually, it’s a stunning film. It’s slow, to give you time to take in the scenes, and often pulls back revealing more.

There’s Kubrick’s beloved narration. Episodes from the book on which it is based are removed.

There are some stunning performances, especially Murray Melvin as Runt.

And the music reflects the story so well.

And then… there’s some duff acting. Ryan O’Neal is presumably doing what his director asked, but the accent varies and the actor seems a bit, er, distracted. A big name star here does not work. And Leon Vitali as the older step-son is another negative.

Despite some negatives, it’s a film to be seen. There’s no cgi here, no electronic score, just decent, honest, old-fashioned film making. It wasn’t a box office success at the time, and, while so many Kubrick titles are available on 4K for home viewing, Barry Lyndon is not. Maybe the medium can’t do it justice. Maybe there’s no market for it, and we can make do with a bluray.

Barry wants money and power and respect, regardless of who he has to walk over and however badly he treats his wife. Perfect for our Trumpian times.