No matter what you put at the bottom of a list, someone is going to say “it’s my favourite, it’s this good and that great…” and so on.
Some people have said this should be thought of as a double album with Revolver. We beg to differ. The cover is poor, and the back still looks like a Fab Four album.
What are our problems with this? It’s a bit folky for us, too much Dylan and Byrds. Many of the songs are pretty dirge-like. There’s nothing wrong with an odd song like that, but we have Girl, Michelle, If I Needed Someone, What Goes On… It’s a bit lethargic, it sounds tired.
Some of the tracks are rejects from Help! or other, earlier albums, and they sound like it.
We listen to this, and at the end we think “ok, ho hum, it’s nothing special”. As a whole we find it unmemorable at best. There are odd bits of goodness in the barely 35 minutes, but it’s just not quite there. If any other band had made it, it would be up there with their best, just here it’s not.
For people who think it’s one of The Beatles best, fine, but we think it is very over-rated. We’re not the only ones.